Skip to content
REDMASSIVE
JASON LOWEAUTHOR / DAD / WORK IN PROGRESS
← Back to the journal

A FEW WORDS / A LITTLE PERSPECTIVE

Kids don’t need to be afraid of you to respect you.

A little controversy for the parenting table: a firm boundary and a kid who feels safe can exist in the same house.

Here’s a sentence that might get a few dads reaching for the comment button: I don’t think my kids need to be afraid of me to respect me.

Before anyone throws a folding chair, let me finish.

I believe kids need boundaries. I believe the answer sometimes has to be no, even when that no is wildly unpopular with the tiny people receiving it. I’m not suggesting we hand a child the keys to the car and ask them to set their own bedtime on the way to Vegas.

I’m asking what we want our kids to learn when we enforce a rule.

Obedience and understanding aren’t always the same thing

A kid can stop doing something because they understand why it matters. They can also stop because they’re worried about what happens when Dad gets mad. From across the room, those two situations might look exactly alike.

I know which kind of relationship I want to build. I want my daughters to be able to tell me when they’ve screwed up, not just when they’ve figured out how to hide it.

That doesn’t mean they’ll always like the consequences. It means the consequence shouldn’t have to make them doubt whether they’re safe coming to me.

Compassion isn’t a free pass

When a kid crosses a line, I can be curious about what happened and still hold the line. Was she overwhelmed? Did she misunderstand? Was she testing a boundary because she’s a human being and that’s one of the things human beings do?

Knowing the reason doesn’t magically erase the behavior. It helps me respond to the actual situation instead of the version my temper invented in the first three seconds.

And yes, sometimes there are safety situations where the first job is to stop the thing immediately. Nobody needs a family meeting while someone is running into traffic. We can talk once everybody’s safely out of the road.

We bring our own childhoods to the table

Some of us grew up in homes where fear and respect got mixed together. Some had loving parents who did the best they knew how with the tools they had. Some had experiences that were much harder than that.

I’m not interested in standing here grading your parents or pretending a blog post can settle every family’s history. I do think we’re allowed to ask which lessons helped us and which ones we’d like to do differently.

That can be an uncomfortable conversation. It can also be a useful one.

Firm and safe can live together

I’m still figuring out how to get this right. I’ll have days when my tone arrives before my judgment and I have to come back, own it, and try again. An apology doesn’t mean the boundary disappears. It means I can be accountable for how I handled it.

I’d rather my daughters know I mean what I say and know they can come to me when things go sideways. I don’t think I have to choose one.

What did respect look like in your house growing up? What are you keeping, and what are you doing differently?

THE GUY BEHIND THE WORDS

Jason Lowe

Dad of four. Arkansas writer, designer, and musician. Working on You Suck at Being a Dad and the ongoing business of being a little better at it.

Meet Jason & read a little of the book ↗
THERE'S MORE WHERE THIS CAME FROM.

THE NEXT CHAPTER.
YOU'RE INVITED.

Book updates and occasional words from a work in progress.

Keep me posted ↗